Should I Buy A Horse With Navicular?

Short Answer

Purchasing a horse with navicular disease may be reasonable if the condition is mild, well‑managed by a veterinarian and farrier, and the price reflects the added risk. However, proceed with caution if the lameness is severe, treatment costs are high, or you lack experience handling chronic hoof issues.

When It Makes Sense

• Good fit: You are an experienced owner or trainer who already works with a qualified equine veterinarian and farrier familiar with navicular management, and you have a budget for ongoing care.
• Good fit: The horse is already on a proven medical and shoeing program, shows consistent performance in low‑impact disciplines (e.g., hunter turnout, light trail), and is priced significantly below market value for a sound horse.

When You Should Avoid It

• Warning sign: The horse exhibits severe, progressive lameness, multiple attempts at treatment have failed, or the diagnosis is recent and unconfirmed.
• Warning sign: You lack access to a specialist farrier or equine veterinarian, or the projected lifetime care costs exceed what you can reliably afford.

Pros and Cons

Pros

• Potentially lower purchase price, allowing entry into ownership for those on a tight budget.
• Opportunity to work with a horse that, when properly managed, can enjoy a comfortable life and light performance, providing educational value.

Cons

• Ongoing veterinary and farrier expenses can be substantial and unpredictable.
• Risk of reduced performance, early retirement, or euthanasia if the disease progresses despite treatment.

Decision Checklist

• Is the navicular disease confirmed by radiographs or advanced imaging, and what is the documented severity?
• Do you have a qualified equine veterinarian and farrier who have successfully managed navicular cases?
• Have you budgeted for at least the first 2–3 years of treatment, shoeing, and possible complications?

Alternatives to Consider

If the risks feel too high, consider purchasing a sound horse of similar age and temperament, or adopt a retired horse without performance expectations. Another option is to lease a horse with navicular disease to gain experience while limiting long‑term financial commitment.

Final Recommendation

Buying a horse with navicular disease can be a viable choice for knowledgeable owners who have professional support and a realistic budget for lifelong care. For most casual riders or first‑time owners, the safer path is to seek a sound horse or a low‑risk alternative. Always consult an equine veterinarian and a specialized farrier before finalizing any purchase involving chronic hoof disease.