Should I Play Red Dead Redemption 1 Before 2?
If you want the originally intended story order and do not mind older gameplay, playing Red Dead Redemption 1 before 2 preserves major reveals and makes the prequel’s callbacks land harder. If you prefer modern mechanics, chronological storytelling, or only have time for one large game, starting with Red Dead Redemption 2 is a sensible alternative. The right choice depends on whether you value release order, time investment, or presentation quality most.