Should I Join The Stormcloaks Or The Imperials?

Short Answer

The best faction in The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim depends on your character's values and the story you want to experience. The Stormcloaks suit players who value Skyrim's independence and religious freedom, while the Imperials appeal to players who prioritize stability and a unified front. This guide breaks down the trade-offs so you can choose confidently, or decide to stay neutral entirely.

When It Makes Sense

  • Good fit: Choose the Stormcloaks if your character values Skyrim’s independence, resents the Empire’s enforcement of the White-Gold Concordat, and wants to restore open Talos worship. This path suits players who enjoy a national-liberation narrative and are willing to accept Ulfric Stormcloak’s controversial leadership.
  • Good fit: Choose the Imperials if your character prioritizes stability, a unified front against the Aldmeri Dominion, and a cosmopolitan vision of Skyrim. This path fits players who value law and order, prefer General Tullius’s disciplined approach, and want to keep the Empire intact.

When You Should Avoid It

  • Warning sign: Avoid committing to either faction if you want to preserve access to certain questlines or characters tied to the opposing side, since the civil-war questline locks out the enemy faction’s storyline. If you enjoy seeing all content on one playthrough, postpone the choice.
  • Warning sign: Avoid the Stormcloaks if you are uncomfortable with their narrative association with xenophobia, particularly the treatment of Dunmer and Argonians in Windhelm, or if you believe a divided Skyrim weakens resistance to the Thalmor. Avoid the Imperials if you object to their enforcement of the Talos ban or their opening attempt to execute the player character.

Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Stormcloaks: Offer a clear underdog story, the promise of religious freedom for Talos worshippers, and a defiant stance against the Aldmeri Dominion’s influence.
  • Imperials: Provide institutional stability, greater military resources, and the strategic argument that a united Empire is better positioned to resist the Thalmor long-term.

Cons

  • Stormcloaks: Risk isolating Skyrim, empower a leader whose policies alienate non-Nord residents, and may ultimately benefit the Thalmor by weakening the Empire.
  • Imperials: Enforce an unpopular religious ban, represent foreign rule to many Nords, and are connected to the harsh introduction where the player is nearly executed at Helgen.

Decision Checklist

  • Which faction’s values align more closely with your character’s backstory and personal beliefs about freedom versus order?
  • Are you more interested in the gameplay rewards and city access of one side, such as Windhelm or Solitude, and can you accept losing the opposing questline?
  • Have you considered completing the main Dragonborn questline first, since the civil-war plot can run alongside it but may affect certain interactions?

Alternatives to Consider

You can remain neutral and ignore the civil-war questline entirely while still completing most of the game, including the main quest. Because The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim allows multiple save files, many players join one faction on a first playthrough and the other on a second. Console and PC players can also use mods or console commands to experience content from both sides without fully committing. Finally, you can delay joining either faction until after exploring both Windhelm and Solitude and speaking with Ralof, Hadvar, Ulfric, and Tullius.

Final Recommendation

Join the Stormcloaks if your character is a Nord nationalist, resents the Talos ban, and prefers a rebellion narrative. Join the Imperials if your character values imperial law, multicultural cooperation, and the strategic argument that unity is strength. Because this is a single-player role-playing decision with no real-world stakes, the best choice is the one that fits your role-play and the story you want to experience; use separate saves if you want to explore both outcomes.

FAQ

Should I join the Stormcloaks or the Imperials?

It depends on your character and the story you want. The Stormcloaks fit players who value independence and religious freedom, while the Imperials suit players who prefer stability, law, and a unified Empire. Because the choice locks one side's questline, many players use separate saves or multiple playthroughs to see both.

What should I consider before joining a faction in Skyrim?

Consider your role-play values, the gameplay rewards you want, whether you care about losing the opposing faction's quests, and whether you have finished or wish to postpone the main Dragonborn storyline. You can also remain neutral or use mods to explore both sides.

References

  1. Bethesda Game Studios. The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim. ZeniMax Media, 2011.

Related Terms

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *