Should I Kill McKay in Far Cry 6?

When It Makes Sense

• Good fit: Killing McKay makes sense if you want the unique wrist gear reward tied to this outcome. If your build focuses on passive bonuses from equipment, the item can be a worthwhile pickup.
• Good fit: It may also make sense if you are role-playing Dani as uncompromising toward Yaran collaborators and prefer a morally direct outcome for this storyline.

When You Should Avoid It

• Warning sign: Avoid killing McKay if your character is low on funds and could use the 5,000 pesos offered for sparing him. The money can be spent on weapons, ammo, vehicles, or camp upgrades.
• Warning sign: Pause if you are trying to earn the achievement or trophy tied to sparing McKay, since that specific outcome may be required depending on platform and patch.

Pros and Cons

Pros

• You receive a unique gear item that cannot be obtained otherwise, adding a permanent equipment option to your inventory.
• The decision aligns with a more aggressive, no-mercy narrative path for players who want a decisive ending to McKay’s plotline.

Cons

• You miss out on the 5,000 pesos payout, which is one of the larger one-time cash rewards available from a single mission choice.
• The story impact is minimal either way, so the choice is mostly about loot rather than meaningful narrative consequences.

Decision Checklist

• Do I need more cash right now for weapons, vehicles, or base improvements?
• Does the unique gear reward fit my current build or playstyle?
• Am I trying to collect achievements, trophies, or completionist rewards that require a specific outcome?

Alternatives to Consider

There is no third option in this encounter, but you can still choose to spare McKay for the money. If you change your mind later, you cannot undo the choice without reloading an earlier save or starting a new playthrough. Before deciding, consider making a manual save so you can experience both outcomes if desired.

Final Recommendation

For most players, the choice should be based on the reward you value more. If you need money early in the campaign, spare McKay. If you want the unique gear item or prefer a more ruthless narrative, kill him. The main story is largely unaffected either way, so pick the outcome that matches your current needs and save beforehand if you want to keep both options open.