Short Answer
When It Makes Sense
- Good fit: You are playing an evil, selfish, or mercenary character who would naturally accept Glut’s offer to overthrow the colony for personal gain.
- Good fit: You want the experience, loot, and temporary ally tied to Glut’s questline, and you do not mind losing the Myconid Colony as a peaceful hub.
When You Should Avoid It
- Warning sign: You want the Myconid Colony to remain a safe resting spot, merchant location, and quest hub for the rest of Act One.
- Warning sign: Your party includes companions who disapprove of killing friendly non-hostile NPCs, which could hurt relationship progress and companion quests.
Pros and Cons
Pros
- You receive quest rewards and experience from helping Glut, including a temporary myconid ally who can fight alongside you.
- You gain access to items, currency, and loot carried by Spaw and the hostile myconids in the colony.
Cons
- The Myconid Colony turns hostile, removing a friendly sanctuary, merchant access, and any remaining peaceful quest resolutions there.
- Several companions, especially good-aligned ones, will lose approval, and some players may feel the act conflicts with a heroic or neutral roleplay path.
Decision Checklist
- Have I finished all the quests, trading, and dialogue I want from the Myconid Colony before turning it hostile?
- Does my current roleplay path support betraying or killing a non-hostile leader for reward?
- Will my core party members approve or disapprove, and how much does companion approval matter in this run?
Alternatives to Consider
If you are unsure, the safest alternative is to refuse Glut’s request and leave Spaw in power. This keeps the colony friendly and lets you complete its quests peacefully. Another option is to avoid Glut entirely, or to side with Glut only after you have completed every interaction you need in the colony. You can also save before the choice and reload if the consequences feel worse than expected.
Final Recommendation
Kill Spaw if you are aiming for an evil or reward-focused run and have already used everything you need from the Myconid Colony. Avoid killing him if you want a stable, friendly Underdark hub and strong companion approval. Because Baldur’s Gate 3 is a roleplay-heavy game with no single “right” answer, pick the path that fits your character’s values and your preferred playstyle.
FAQ
Should I kill Spaw in BG3?
Killing Spaw makes sense for evil, mercenary, or reward-focused runs that want Glut's support and associated loot. Avoid it if you want the Myconid Colony to stay friendly and useful as a sanctuary and merchant hub.
Leave a Reply