Should I Sell Opal And Amber Botw?

When It Makes Sense

• Good fit: You are early in the game, low on rupees, and need to purchase critical items like a better weapon or a key upgrade.
• Good fit: You have surplus Opal and Amber beyond what you need for armor upgrades or village requests, and you want to free inventory space.

When You Should Avoid It

• Warning sign: You are planning to complete the Amber and Opal armor sets, which require these gems as crafting materials.
• Warning sign: You are near a side quest or shrine that specifically asks for Opal or Amber as payment for a reward.

Pros and Cons

Pros

• Provides an immediate influx of rupees, enabling purchases that can accelerate early-game progression.
• Clears inventory slots, making it easier to carry other valuable items.

Cons

• Reduces the pool of materials needed for high‑level armor upgrades that offer significant defense bonuses.
• May limit your ability to fulfill future quest requirements that request Opal or Amber.

Decision Checklist

• Do I have enough alternative materials to craft the armor I want without Opal or Amber?
• Am I currently short on rupees for an essential purchase?
• Will selling these gems prevent me from completing any upcoming quests or side‑quests?

Alternatives to Consider

Instead of selling, you could store Opal and Amber in a treasure chest at a stable, use them to upgrade armor gradually, or trade them for specific items at the Goron merchants. Another low‑risk option is to keep them until you reach a point in the game where rupee income is steadier.

Final Recommendation

If you are early in your adventure, struggling with rupees, and have excess gems beyond your upgrade plans, selling Opal and Amber can be a practical short‑term solution. However, once you begin working toward the Amber or Opal armor sets, or when major quests demand these items, it is wiser to retain them. Always assess your current resource balance and, for high‑stakes decisions, consult experienced players or community guides.