Should I Tell Ominis That Sebastian Showed Me The Undercroft?

When It Makes Sense

• Good fit: When Ominis is a trusted ally whose knowledge of the Undercroft could help protect the group from unseen threats, sharing the information may enable coordinated action.
• Good fit: If Sebastian explicitly asked you to relay the discovery to Ominus for a joint plan, honesty fulfills a clear request and keeps the chain of communication intact.

When You Should Avoid It

• Warning sign: If the Undercroft contains sensitive or dangerous secrets that Ominis is not prepared to handle, revealing the location could expose him to unnecessary risk.
• Warning sign: When Sebastian shared the Undercroft with you under a confidence agreement, breaking that trust could damage your relationship and undermine future cooperation.

Pros and Cons

Pros

• Transparency can build trust between you and Ominis, fostering stronger teamwork and shared situational awareness.
• Early disclosure may allow Ominis to take precautionary measures, preventing accidents or misuse of the Undercroft.

Cons

• Revealing the information could put Ominis in danger if the Undercroft is guarded by traps, hostile entities, or political intrigue.
• Breach of confidence may damage your credibility with Sebastian and others who expect discretion.

Decision Checklist

• Do you have explicit permission from Sebastian to share the Undercroft details?
• Is Ominis equipped, knowledgeable, and willing to handle the potential risks associated with the Undercroft?
• What are the possible consequences for the broader group if the information remains hidden versus if it is disclosed?

Alternatives to Consider

Instead of a direct confession, you could: (1) ask Sebastian for clarification on how the information should be handled; (2) suggest a joint meeting where both Sebastian and Ominis can discuss the Undercroft together, preserving confidentiality; or (3) provide a vague warning about a “potentially hazardous area” without specifying the exact location, allowing Ominis to act cautiously without full disclosure.

Final Recommendation

In most ordinary circumstances, disclose the Undercroft to Ominis only if you have clear permission from Sebastian or if the safety of the group outweighs confidentiality concerns. When trust, expertise, and consent align, sharing can be beneficial; otherwise, seek clarification or use a lower‑risk communication method. For high‑stakes scenarios—such as life‑threatening dangers or legal ramifications—consult a trusted mentor or authority before proceeding.