Should I Draft J.J. McCarthy?
Drafting J.J. McCarthy makes the most sense in Superflex and dynasty rookie formats where you can wait on quarterback development, especially if he is available after the top-tier rookie passers. In one-quarterback redraft leagues, he is usually a risky early pick because his rookie-year role and statistics will depend heavily on his NFL landing spot. Weigh his athletic tools and winning pedigree against the opportunity cost of safer skill-position rookies.