Should I Destroy The Mines in Avowed?

When It Makes Sense

• Good fit: You are roleplaying a character who opposes the faction operating the mines, such as a rebel, humanitarian, or environmentally minded hero, and want your actions to match your principles.
• Good fit: Destroying the mines advances a storyline you prefer, such as protecting a nearby settlement, cutting off an enemy’s supplies, or completing a quest objective that requires sabotage.

When You Should Avoid It

• Warning sign: You want to stay friendly with the faction that owns or profits from the mines, because destroying their assets may lower reputation, trigger hostility, or lock future quests and rewards.
• Warning sign: You have not checked your companions’ likely reactions; party members in Avowed often approve or disapprove of major moral choices, which can affect their loyalty and romance arcs.

Pros and Cons

Pros

• Can create a satisfying roleplay outcome for characters who prioritize justice, environmental protection, or weakening oppressive forces.
• May unlock alternative quest resolutions, rewards, or story paths tied to siding with the faction or settlement that wanted the mines destroyed.

Cons

• May remove access to resources, merchants, or side content connected to the mines if the location becomes hostile or uninhabitable.
• Could damage companion relationships or faction standing in ways that limit dialogue, romance, or ending outcomes later in the game.

Decision Checklist

• Which faction or settlement benefits from the mines, and do I want their support later in the game?
• How will my current companions likely react to the destruction, and does companion approval matter for my playthrough?
• Have I saved recently so I can reload if the consequences feel worse than expected?

Alternatives to Consider

Before committing to destruction, look for dialogue options that let you negotiate, expose wrongdoing, or reach a compromise. Some quests may allow partial sabotage rather than total demolition. You can also side with the mine operators if their goals align with your character’s interests, or simply leave the mines alone and pursue unrelated objectives. If you want to see both outcomes, make a hard save before the choice point and revisit it later.

Final Recommendation

Destroy the mines if your character’s ethics and preferred story path demand it, especially when protecting allies or undermining enemies. Keep the mines intact if you value faction reputation, companion approval, or potential economic benefits tied to the location. Because Avowed choices can ripple through later quests, save before acting, and consider checking a current walkthrough or official guide for the specific quest to confirm exactly what changes in your version of the game.