Should I Give the Sword of Jyggalag or Amber?

When It Makes Sense

• Good fit: Giving the Sword of Jyggalag may be reasonable when the weapon does not suit your character’s combat style. In many Elder Scrolls releases it appears as a two-handed claymore or unique artifact with a niche role; if you rely on one-handed weapons, magic, stealth, or ranged attacks, the sword may spend most of the game unused. In that case, trading it for Amber or a quest reward that advances crafting, faction standing, or roleplay objectives can be the more practical choice.
• Good fit: The exchange can also make sense for players who value short-term progression over long-term collection. Amber is a crafting material tied to Shivering Isles and Creation Club content, often used to forge or upgrade gear that fills a specific equipment slot. If your current loadout lacks a solid piece of armor or a weapon and the offered path provides a clear upgrade, handing over the sword may speed up your build more than keeping a trophy.

When You Should Avoid It

• Warning sign: Avoid giving away the sword if you are a completionist or if the weapon is flagged as a unique, non-replenishable item. Once turned in, many quest objects can only be recovered through console commands, mods, or starting over, which is especially frustrating on console platforms that lack command-line access. If there is any doubt about reacquisition, keep the rarer artifact and look for another way to obtain Amber.
• Warning sign: Be cautious when the quest prompt is ambiguous about what you will receive in return, or when you are using mods, Creation Club add-ons, or an older patch where scripting may behave unexpectedly. Some exchanges appear to offer Amber but do not deliver the expected quantity, or the reward may scale poorly with your level. When the outcome is unclear, pause before committing and consult a version-specific wiki or guide.

Pros and Cons

Pros

• Trading the sword can remove a heavy or rarely used item from your inventory while moving a quest or faction relationship forward. For characters who do not use two-handed melee weapons, the immediate benefit of a completed objective or crafting material often outweighs holding onto an ornament.
• The alternative reward may better match your current needs. Amber can contribute to armor, weapons, or decorative gear, and completing the exchange may unlock additional recipes, vendor access, or story content that you would otherwise miss.

Cons

• The Sword of Jyggalag is typically a unique artifact tied to major Daedric Prince lore, so giving it away can leave a permanent gap in a collection. If you later switch to a melee-focused build or want to display the weapon, you may regret the loss.
• The return value is not always equal. Depending on your level, the Amber reward may be common elsewhere, and the sword may have a higher base value or stronger enchantment than the gear you craft with the materials. Exchanging a one-of-a-kind item for a stack of replaceable ore is often a poor long-term trade.

Decision Checklist

• Have you saved recently, or are you willing to reload an earlier file if the outcome disappoints you?
• Does your current character actually use the Sword of Jyggalag, or would the Amber or crafted reward provide a more immediate power increase?
• Are you playing the original, patched, or modded version of the game, and have you confirmed that the trade is reversible or repeatable?

Alternatives to Consider

If the choice is reversible or part of a testable quest, save the game right before the hand-in and try each outcome to compare rewards. On PC platforms, console commands or safe modding tools can often restore a mistakenly traded unique item, while console players may prefer to keep the sword and farm Amber from known creature drops or vendors. In some versions, storing the sword in a player home or display case preserves the artifact without affecting quest progression, letting you keep options open. When neither reward seems essential, postponing the decision until you have finished the relevant questline is usually the lowest-risk path.

Final Recommendation

As a general rule, keep the Sword of Jyggalag if you collect unique artifacts, plan to use melee weapons, or are uncertain about reacquiring it later. Give it away only when the offered Amber or quest reward clearly improves your current build and you have a recent save to fall back on. Because exact consequences differ across The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion, the Shivering Isles expansion, and the Skyrim Creation Club “Saints & Seducers” content, check a current, version-specific source before you finalize the trade. For high-stakes decisions outside of gameplay, consult a qualified professional; for this in-game choice, the safest approach is to save first and choose the reward that best serves your character.