Short Answer
When It Makes Sense
- Good fit: you want an assassin-themed playstyle with exclusive rewards. The Dark Brotherhood questline is built around stealth, infiltration, and targeted kills. If your character is already a sneaky archer, blade-wielding rogue, or morally flexible adventurer, the faction gives you themed work, a hidden sanctuary in Cheydinhal, and some of the most memorable quest writing in the game. It is also one of the better ways to earn large amounts of gold quickly through contracts.
- Good fit: you value unique items, a special mount, and a dark narrative. Membership grants access to equipment and services that are otherwise unavailable, including the undying horse Shadowmere, the Blade of Woe, and a durable set of assassin armor. The storyline explores betrayal, loyalty, and the internal politics of Sithis and the Night Mother, making it a satisfying arc for players who enjoy morally complex faction stories.
When You Should Avoid It
- Warning sign: you are roleplaying a lawful, heroic, or devoutly good character. Joining requires that you commit cold-blooded murder to attract the Brotherhood’s attention, and nearly every contract afterward asks you to kill named or unwitting targets. If your character concept is a noble knight, a holy warrior, or a law-abiding citizen, the Dark Brotherhood will feel out of character and may undermine the story you are trying to tell.
- Warning sign: you want to preserve specific NPCs or keep your criminal record clean. Some Brotherhood targets are characters who also appear in other questlines or who provide services in town. Accepting a contract can remove merchants, trainers, or quest givers from your game. Additionally, the initiation and many contracts create bounty and murder counts that can complicate guard interactions in Cyrodiil.
Pros and Cons
Pros
- High-value, one-of-a-kind rewards. The Brotherhood gives you Shadowmere, one of the most durable and convenient mounts in the game, plus the Blade of Woe and a set of armor that boosts useful stealth skills. You also receive a steady income from assassination contracts and access to a safe home base with trainers and merchants.
- Engaging, well-written quest content. The faction storyline is widely considered one of the strongest in Oblivion. It includes creative assassination scenarios, twists, and a satisfying climax that ties into the lore of Sithis and the Night Mother.
Cons
- You must commit murder and remain a criminal. The guild is not a thieves’ guild with rules against killing; it is a cult of assassins. You will be asked to kill repeatedly, and your journal will record those deaths for the rest of the playthrough. This can clash with any heroic reputation you have built.
- Some targets may affect other questlines. Because certain contracts target named NPCs, joining can lock you out of quests, services, or relationships you might have wanted to pursue later. Once an assassination target dies, the only way to undo it is to reload an earlier save.
Decision Checklist
- Does this choice fit your character’s moral code, or would joining feel like a betrayal of the roleplay you have established?
- Are you comfortable killing the targets the Brotherhood assigns, including characters who may be useful elsewhere in the game?
- Have you made a hard save before sleeping and receiving Lucien Lachance’s visit, so you can revert if you later regret joining?
Alternatives to Consider
If you like stealth and faction content but not murder, the Thieves Guild offers a criminal path built around burglary, lockpicking, and non-lethal heists. For lawful characters, the Fighters Guild and Mages Guild provide full faction questlines, guild halls, and useful rewards without requiring assassinations. You can also simply refuse the Dark Brotherhood invitation by killing Lucien Lachance or ignoring his offer, allowing you to continue a hero or freelance adventurer playthrough.
Final Recommendation
Join the Dark Brotherhood if you want a dark, stealth-focused storyline with strong rewards and your character concept can justify assassination. Skip it if you are playing a lawful hero, want to keep specific NPCs alive, or prefer factions that do not require murder. Because the choice is effectively permanent once you accept, save your game before committing and consult a reliable Oblivion quest reference if you are unsure which targets might affect other plans.
FAQ
Should I join the Dark Brotherhood in Oblivion?
It depends on your character and goals. Join if you want stealth contracts, unique rewards like Shadowmere and the Blade of Woe, and a dark storyline. Skip it if you are playing a lawful hero or want to avoid killing named NPCs.
Leave a Reply