Should I Kill Amadio in Avowed?

When It Makes Sense

• Good fit: Your character is following a ruthless, militant, or vengeance-driven path where eliminating named threats aligns with your roleplay and companion values.
• Good fit: You have exhausted dialogue options and confirmed that Amadio is hostile, that no peaceful or alternate resolution remains, and that removing him advances your immediate quest objective.

When You Should Avoid It

• Warning sign: You are pursuing a diplomatic, heroic, or completionist run where killing named NPCs can lock quests, vendor access, lore conversations, or faction storylines.
• Warning sign: The encounter still offers persuasion, intimidation, bribery, deception, or non-lethal paths that you have not yet tried.

Pros and Cons

Pros

• Eliminates a potential recurring threat and can immediately resolve a hostile encounter or quest obstacle.
• May provide loot, experience, or access to areas or information tied to the confrontation.

Cons

• Can permanently remove an NPC who later offers quests, trades, lore, or story branches, reducing replay value on a single save.
• May lower companion approval and damage faction reputation, which can shift dialogue options, prices, and endgame possibilities.

Decision Checklist

• Have I saved recently so I can reload if the consequences are unwelcome?
• Have I exhausted all dialogue and skill-check options to see whether Amadio can be persuaded, intimidated, bribed, or bypassed?
• Which companions are present, and will killing him help or hurt their approval and related companion quests?

Alternatives to Consider

Before attacking, explore dialogue persuasion, intimidation, bribery, deception, or simply leaving the area if the encounter is optional. Some RPG choices allow you to return later with better faction standing, new information, or different companions. If combat is unavoidable, look for non-lethal takedown options or opportunities to let another NPC resolve the conflict for you.

Final Recommendation

Kill Amadio in Avowed if your playstyle favors decisive combat, no peaceful path remains, and your companions support lethal action. Spare or negotiate with him if you value quest flexibility, companion approval, faction reputation, or a completionist experience. Because exact consequences depend on your current quest state, prior choices, and party composition, save beforehand and consult an up-to-date Avowed quest guide or community wiki for the specific branch you want.