Short Answer
When It Makes Sense
- Good fit: You are committed to keeping Astarion in your party and want to protect him from being captured or killed by the Gur hunter.
- Good fit: You are playing a pragmatic, ruthless, or evil-aligned party that prioritizes immediate loot and companion approval over sparing a hostile NPC.
When You Should Avoid It
- Warning sign: You want to keep Astarion as a companion; helping Gandrel capture or kill him will permanently remove Astarion from your party.
- Warning sign: You are trying to play a pacifist, heroic, or lore-focused run where conflicts are resolved through dialogue rather than bloodshed.
Pros and Cons
Pros
- Killing Gandrel earns Astarion’s approval and secures his continued presence in your party for the rest of the game.
- You can loot Gandrel’s equipment, which includes useful early-game gear and supplies.
Cons
- It closes off the option to learn more about the Gur and their hunt for Astarion through peaceful dialogue.
- It may conflict with a good-aligned or merciful character concept, limiting role-playing options.
Decision Checklist
- Do you want Astarion to remain a companion, or are you willing to lose him from your party?
- Have you exhausted dialogue options such as deception, persuasion, or intimidation?
- Does your character’s moral alignment and role-play direction allow killing a hunter who is simply doing his job?
Alternatives to Consider
If you do not want to kill Gandrel, you can lie about Astarion’s whereabouts, use persuasion or intimidation to make him leave, or simply refuse to cooperate without drawing weapons. If you want to remove Astarion from your party deliberately, you can let Gandrel take him. For a non-violent resolution, high Charisma checks or class features can defuse the encounter entirely.
Final Recommendation
For most playthroughs that include Astarion, killing Gandrel is the mechanically simplest way to keep Astarion safe and loyal. If you value a pacifist, heroic, or lore-focused run, use deception or persuasion instead. The choice should align with your party composition and role-playing goals rather than any single “correct” outcome.
FAQ
Should I kill Gandrel in BG3?
Killing Gandrel is usually the best mechanical choice if you want to keep Astarion as a companion and earn his approval. If you prefer a peaceful or heroic run, use persuasion, intimidation, or deception to make Gandrel leave instead.
What happens if I let Gandrel take Astarion?
If you help Gandrel, Astarion will be captured and permanently removed from your party. This is generally only desirable if you specifically want to remove Astarion from your active group.
Can I get Gandrel's loot without killing him?
No, Gandrel's unique equipment is only available if he dies in combat. If you resolve the encounter peacefully, you forfeit that loot but avoid losing companion approval.
Does killing Gandrel affect the main story?
Gandrel is a minor NPC, so killing him has limited long-term story consequences. The main impact is on Astarion's approval and your immediate party composition.
Leave a Reply