Should I Lie In Lies Of P?

When It Makes Sense

• Good fit: You want the story path associated with Pinocchio becoming more human. Consistently choosing compassionate lies at major story moments generally leads toward the “Rise of P” ending route and unlocks related content.
• Good fit: You are supporting an NPC who needs reassurance or hope rather than blunt honesty. Some companion questlines progress more favorably, or avoid premature failure, when you respond with an emotional lie.

When You Should Avoid It

• Warning sign: You are aiming for a truth-based ending or achievement. Some endings and trophy or achievement conditions are tied to telling the truth at critical moments, so a lie can push you onto a different path.
• Warning sign: You do not have a recent backup save and you are unsure how an NPC will react. A lie can close off a questline, alter rewards, or change later dialogue in ways the game does not always clearly flag.

Pros and Cons

Pros

• Lying can unlock story branches, cutscenes, and the ending route linked to Pinocchio’s growing humanity.
• Certain NPCs respond better to hopeful or protective lies, which can extend their questlines or improve their emotional outcomes.

Cons

• A single lie at a key moment can shift your ending path or lock you out of truth-related content for that playthrough.
• Lies do not always produce a clearly better result; some backfire emotionally or alter NPC fates in ways you may regret.

Decision Checklist

• Do I know which ending or achievement I am targeting in this playthrough?
• Have I made a manual backup save before a major dialogue choice so I can undo an unwanted consequence?
• Am I lying to support an NPC’s arc, or am I guessing because the prompt looks interesting?

Alternatives to Consider

If you want to see every outcome without committing, use multiple save files or plan several playthroughs. Many players do one truth-focused run and one lie-focused run. Spoiler-free choice guides can also flag which dialogue nodes are mechanically significant, letting you role-play freely in minor conversations while being deliberate at critical ones.

Final Recommendation

For a first playthrough, pick the answer that fits your role-play instinct and save often. If you are achievement-hunting or want a specific ending, plan your choices and keep backup saves. To experience the full story, expect to play through Lies of P at least twice with different truth and lie patterns. Because individual questlines can be complex, consult a reputable guide if you are worried about missing a specific item, boss, or ending.